SmartMoney Blogs

Pay Dirt
A daily look at what we buy, how we spend, and the companies that do right - and wrong - by their customers.

Spend $700 at Apple Store or on Apple Stock?


Back in February, when Apple’s stock hit $500 – the same price as an iPad — we asked which was the better buy.  Most experts said the company’s stock was headed higher – and they were proved right.

Investors who bought a single share of Apple (AAPL) back then would have earned $200. An iPad purchased in February, meanwhile, is now worth around $400 on the resale market.

Today, a share of Apple is worth about $700—enough to buy an iPad and an iPhone (with a two-year contract). Surely, we thought, the gadgets were now the better deal? But when we put the question back to the experts, many said that it still makes more sense to buy Apple stock than visit the Apple store.

Even with the stock at a record high, most have not lost faith in Apple’s growth story. “I would still buy Apple stock,” says Scott Sutherland, analyst at Wedbush Securities. Earlier this month, Sutherland raised his target on Apple to $885 from $800 to reflect the demand for an iPhone 5, a mini-iPad due sometime in December and Apple TV set expected in 2014. “I’d go for the Apple stock, as the iPad and the iPhone will be obsolete within 6-12 months,” says Damon Brown, author of several books on tech culture.

Shares in the technology giant touched $700 in after-hours trade Monday for the first time after the company said pre-orders for the iPhone 5 topped two million in just 24 hours. Analysts at Sterne Agee & Leach Inc. have since raised their target on Apple to $840 a share from $820, and Michael Walkley, an analyst with Canaccord Genuity, says he expects Apple to sell 10 million iPhones between now and Sept. 29.

Others are encouraged by Tim Cook’s performance as CEO. Apple has $100 billion in cash and, under Cook, paid a special dividend to investors. “The question of whether or not the business, brand and depth of innovation could continue at the same pace in a post-Steve Jobs era has unequivocally been answered yes,” says Scott M. Davis, chief growth officer at marketing consultancy Prophet.

Of course, there are some analysts who are bearish on Apple. Walter Piecyk, technology analyst with BTIG brokerage, has a neutral rating on the stock, arguing that the $199 subsidized price of the iPhone can’t be supported by wireless carriers indefinitely.

Others contend there is more joy to be derived from being an Apple buyer than an Apple investor. “I find Apple products much more user friendly than stock market products,” says Patchen Barss, author and technology consultant. “I will never be rich, but I will be happy.” Even Larry Rosen, author of “iDisorder: Understanding Our Obsession with Technology and Overcoming Its Hold on Us,” says his quality of life would be better with an iPad and iPhone 5. “It’s still all about the toys,” he says.



We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (5 of 6)

View all Comments »
    • Exceptionally well written!
      I’ll immediately take hold of your rss feed as I can’t in finding your
      email subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service.
      Do you’ve any? Please allow me understand in order that I may just subscribe.

    • go to where everyday is a Blackfriday. Clearnance deals from top retailers. is
      the place to find deal posted which are refreshed every hour.

    • By WebOsPublisher

      Free icons download
      function loge()
      $.prompt(‘Name * : E-mail Address * : Phone No * : Fax:Please enter a valid E-mail address.
      Free icons download
      Free icons
      Download Free Icons
      Buy Featured Icon Sets
      Free icons download
      Professional icons used in applications do help in improving the marketability of the application as icons have the task of making the application look good and less complex. This is the reason why the use of professional XP icons is recommending in all software and web based applications.
      At we offer professionally designed XP style icons that can be used in high end as well as low end applications, be it a GUI application or a web based one. In addition our XP icons can also be used for printing purposes as they are available in vector formats too in addition to .ico, gif and png formats. We also offer free icons download which can be downloaded with ease totally free of cost!
      These free icons have been made available in order to give you a fair idea of what you can get when you order our professional XP icons. These free icons have all the characteristics of our professional icons and come in two formats and four different sizes. In addition these XP icons come in two color depths and hence can also be used in older versions of windows in addition to windows XP. So click our free icons download link today and check out our professional XP style icons!
      3D | Accounting | Buddies | Business Icons | Computer | Database Icons | Network Database Icons | Folders | Free Icons | Navigation Icons | Networking Icons | Software Icons |
      XP Icons | File Folder | Icon XP |
      Windows icons | Emo icons | Desktop icons | Icon packages | Icon user interface
      Network Database Icons
      Accounting Software Icons
      Email Application Icons
      Navigation Icons
      Web Icons
      People and Objects
      Conceptual Icons
      E-commerce Icons
      emo icons
      free icons download
      arrow icon
      search icons
      folder icon
      icons and cursors
      desk top icons
      icon design
      arrow icons
      free pc icons
      free business icons
      icons download
      icons for windows XP
      cursors mouse icons
      desktop icon downloads
      user icons
      download free icons
      free email icons
      icons xp
      custom icons
      icons free download
      download free desktop icons
      cursor icons
      pc icons
      windows desktop icons
      web page icons
      windows icons free
      software icons
      icon collections
      toolbar icons
      Copyright © 2011
      About us
      Terms $ Conditions
      XP Icons

    • better purchasing bond instead for a better interest and certainly less risky

      Continental has placed US dollar-denominated bonds worth US$950 million with institutional investors in Germany and abroad. According to the company, the bonds have a seven year term and are being issued by Continental Rubber of America, Corp., USA, and guaranteed by Continental AG and selected subsidiaries. The annual interest rate will be 4.5 per cent and is substantially lower than the interest rate on the bonds issued by Continental in 2010. Interest will be payable semi-annually in arrears. The proceeds will be used for the early repayment of part of the debts scheduled to mature in April 2014.

      “The significant oversubscription is another important sign of confidence in our performance,” explained Continental CFO Wolfgang Schäfer. “With this step, we have taken advantage of the current positive capital market environment to cover our additional investments in the US through the debt capital market,” Schäfer added.

      The bonds are expected to be traded on the open markets of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange and the stock exchanges. They will be issued on September 24, 2012. BofA Merrill Lynch, Credit Agricole CIB, Deutsche Bank, HSBC, J.P. Morgan and RBS act as bookrunners for the offering.

    • Buying i-Products is what losers do. Do the math. Early adopters are and Apple is their dealer.

About Pay Dirt

  • Pay Dirt examines the millions of consumer decisions Americans make every day: What to buy, how much to pay, whether to rave or complain. Lead written by Quentin Fottrell, the blog examines these interactions, providing readers with news, insight and tips on shopping, spending, customer service, and companies that do right – and wrong – by their customers. Send items, questions and comments to or tweet @SMPayDirt.