SmartMoney Blogs

Pay Dirt
A daily look at what we buy, how we spend, and the companies that do right - and wrong - by their customers.

Health Care Premiums on the Rise. Again.

Despite the Obama administration’s ambitious health care overhaul, insurance premiums are on the rise.


The May 2011 medical index by consulting firm Milliman Inc. says health care costs for a family of four will rise 7.3% in 2011 to $19,393 for those insured through work, with employee out-of-pocket expenses up 9.2% this year versus 6.6% last year. “Trends in health care spending still far exceed most other goods and services,” it said.

Milliman’s researchers said that employees are paying around $8,000 of the total annual healthcare costs, higher than other areas of consumer spending, as employers offer health plans with higher deductibles, and co-insurance and co-payment limits to control costs and to encourage workers to use medical care more selectively. That includes $4,728 in an employee contribution and $3,280 in employee out-of-pocket costs.

Premiums are rising even faster in Massachusetts, even after that state introduced its own health care reform in 2006 requiring residents to buy health insurance in that state, according to Consumer Watchdog. Insurance premiums for a single plan have risen 13.4% nationally from 2006 to 2009 versus a much larger 18.4% in Massachusetts, while premiums for a family plan rose 19.8% in Massachusetts in the same period, versus 14.5% nationally.

Consumers are increasingly unable to afford the coverage they have, the report says: “Massachusetts is hard‐pressed to maintain affordability. Premiums in the state remain the second-­highest in the nation and rising costs are threatening to unbalance the state budget.” It adds, “The passage of the federal [healthcare] reform triggered further outsize increases by insurance companies apparently seeking to establish high base rates in advance of the law’s implementation.”

This echoes conclusions in a recent study in the American Journal of Medicine, which concluded that the percentage of personal bankruptcies related to medical bills or illness in Massachusetts hasn’t improved much since 2006. Medical bankruptcies as a percentage of personal bankruptcies eased only slightly to 52.9% from 59.3%.

A spokeswoman for the National Association of Health Underwriters says, “Even in a highly regulated market like Massachusetts, premiums continue to rise because consumers continue to treat health care as if it is a free service. If we are more aware of where we are spending our health care dollars, we can more effectively provide quality care for all Americans,” she says.

“Health insurance is expensive because health care is expensive,” the spokeswoman adds, citing a weaker economy putting pressure on employers to decrease contributions, a shortage of primary care physicians in rural areas, and insurance carriers pulling out of the individual market and discontinuing child-only policies.

What do you think is behind these rises?


We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (5 of 29)

View all Comments »
    • By WebOsPublisher

      Dribbble – 1980s Television Set icon by Adam Whitcroft
      Sign in
      Find Designers
      Sign up
      1980s Television Set icon
      by Adam Whitcroft
      Feb 14, 2012
      5 buckets
      13 Responses
      Adam Whitcroft
      I wanted to get in on the NES Icon Battle #1 but kinda missed the boat. I had already started on the television so thought why not finish it.
      Having a ton of fun with these icons at the moment!
      10 months ago
      Dan Eden
      Yummy. That speaker grille is divine!
      10 months ago
      Daryl Ginn
      10 months ago
      Natalie Rooke
      I’m getting in on some icon battlin’ right now.
      10 months ago
      Todd Coleman
      Very nice! I had a similar tv in my room when I was a kid, nice memories.
      10 months ago
      Joshua Hibbert
      Holy smokes Adam, this is unreal!
      10 months ago
      Yoga Perdana
      love it!
      10 months ago
      Dan Eden
      @Natalie Rooke yay!
      10 months ago
      Adam Whitcroft
      @Todd Coleman, @Joshua Hibbert, @Yoga Perdana thanks guys!
      10 months ago
      Tim Potter
      10 months ago
      Luke Jones
      This looks bad ass!
      10 months ago
      Adam Whitcroft
      @Tim Potter @Luke Jones Thanks chaps!
      10 months ago
      Joaquim Marques Nielsen
      Retro! Gotta love!
      9 months ago
      Ads via The Deck
      More by Adam Whitcroft
      keyboard shortcuts: ← previous shot → next shot L or F like
      Show and tell for designers.
      70,042,906,943 pixels dribbbled
      Copyright © 2009-2012 Dribbble LLC. All screenshots © their respective owners. Handcrafted in Salem, Massachusetts USA.
      Hosted by
      // Move Deck ad content from loading area to display location
      var _gaq = _gaq || [];
      _gaq.push(['_setAccount', 'UA-24041469-1']);
      var ga = document.createElement(‘script’); ga.type = ‘text/javascript’; ga.async = true;
      ga.src = (‘https:’ == document.location.protocol ? ‘https://ssl’ : ‘www’) + ‘’;
      var s = document.getElementsByTagName(‘script’)[0]; s.parentNode.insertBefore(ga, s);

    • By WebOsPublisher

      var addthis_config = “data_track_clickback”: true ; ForumFreeAdvertisements#adsCol .dsLiftedAds

      /* padding-top: 10px; width:480px;*/
      margin: auto;
      margin-top: 10px;
      text-align: center;
      Free Software Leader Richard Stallman: Amazon Search Integration …Free software leader Richard Stallman claims Ubuntu amounts to spyware with Amazon search integrated into the "dash" of its Unity interface. He is..Alex Williams8 Hours 38 Minutes Kills Free Google Apps For Business, Now Only Offering …Google has announced a change to Google Apps for Business — ending the free version of the product, offering only its Premium version which costs $50 per use..Natasha Lomas23 Hours 6 Minutes Discontinues Free Version of Google Apps for BusinessesGoogle has discontinued the free version of Google Apps for businesses.Stan SchroederFriday, December 07, 2012 2:24 Partners Up With Gap, Giving Free Gift Vouchers To …TaskRabbit is tying up with Gap to raise awareness for its brand. As part of the partnership, Gap customers shopping in stores throughout San Francisco and Ne..Ryan Lawler16 Hours 2 Minutes Stops Offering Google Apps for Free, Focuses on …Google has stopped offering Google Apps for free. New users will have to pay for a subscription-based account, or use its free consumer-facing services.Jon RussellThursday, December 06, 2012 10:21
      encyclopedia result
      Free may refer to: Political freedom Economic freedom Something given or supplied without payment (gratis) Gratis versus Libre, the distinction between the two meanings above See the full encyclopedia entry at Wikipeda »Images
      Free | FanuMusic.View ImageView PageFree L2TP VPN | Best Free L2TP Protocol | VPN Service for Free L2TPView ImageView PageWHAT’S FREE TODAY? Freebies from Chili’s, Bob Evans, Clinique $ MoreView ImageView PageFree Beacon" — Breaking News, Politics, National SecurityView ImageView PageFree DISH Channels In October | DISH TV BlogView ImageView PageFree Icons – Download Free Mac OS X Icons and Flags | Icon DrawerView ImageView PageBek Davis Web $ Graphic Design | Free Website Design: Sound To …View ImageView PageBrowse icon sets | Icon Search EngineView ImageView Page
      Haley Reinhart – FreeMusic video by Haley Reinhart performing Free. (C) 2012 19 Recordings, Inc.Friday, 07 December 2012 02:39:32Graffiti6 – FreeMusic video by Graffiti6 performing “Free”. Download “Free” from Graffiti6′s debut album ‘Colours’ on iTunes: (P) (C) 2011 NWFree Music LLP under exclusive license to Capitol Records. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction is a violation of applicable laws. Manufactured by Capitol Records, LLC, 1750 North Vine Street, Hollywood, CA 90028.Friday, 07 December 2012 12:20:05Free – All Right Now [totp][Video] Free – All Right Now [totp] (Wiggy St Helens UK 2008)Friday, 07 December 2012 13:20:03Free – All Right Now RAREThis is a very rare clip released Circa 1969 of Free performing All Right Now (live). Released in Australia in B&W. My favourite clip by this band and highlights Paul Kossoff’s signature vibrato. Best lead ever done by Kossoff!Friday, 07 December 2012 14:44:15Free Mr BigRare promo clip of Free performing Mr Big live in about 1971.Wednesday, 05 December 2012 01:34:03Natalia Kills – Free ft. will.i.amNatalia Kills performing Free. (C) 2011 Interscope RecordsFriday, 07 December 2012 14:42:59 share this pageNews
      Kevin Durant tops Kobe Bryant as Thunder hold off Lakers – USA TODAYBryant followed Durant’s two free throws with a 3-pointer from the corner to get the deficit down to four with 15 seconds left. Durant hit two foul shots and Meeks airballed a three-pointer as the rally fizzled. "They’re a tough team," Durant said …1 Hours 28 Minutes agousatoday.comRelated News:Parker leads balanced Spurs past Rockets 114-92 Yahoo! Sports4 Hours 0 Minutes agoParker Leads Spurs Past Rockets Bleacher Report1 Hours 53 Minutes agoSupreme Court to Hear Two Challenges to Gay Marriage – New York TimesThere was reason to think that Justice Elena Kagan was not free to hear an appeal from the Boston case because she had worked on it or a related case as United States solicitor general. The current solicitor general, Donald B. Verrilli Jr., gave the …11 Hours 31 Minutes agonytimes.comRelated News:Edie Windsor Responds To Supreme Court Agreeing To Hear Her DOMA Case Huffington Post7 Hours 6 Minutes agoAP Top News at 11:49 pm EST Boston.com5 Hours 51 Minutes agoAdvocates, leaders in Texas speak on Supreme Court move on gay marriage … Austin American-Statesman3 Hours 57 Minutes agoPay Wall Push: Why Newspapers Are Hopping Over the Picket Fence – New York Times (blog)But now The Post is contemplating a model in which the homepage and section fronts will be free, but the rest will require a subscription, which is a pretty nifty way to allow for snacking while hoping that people stick around to eat. So what changed?11 Hours 18 Minutes agomediadecoder.blogs.nytimes.comThunder Jolting Foes At Both Ends – (blog)“That’s easy to say,” Lakers coach Mike D’Antoni said when asked if his team should have defended Westbrook better during his 14-point, four assist free-for-all in the second quarter. “I don’t think anybody in this group is going to guard him.” And …0 Hours 31 Minutes News:Thunder Hold off Lakers’ Late Charge, Win 114-108 ABC News2 Hours 32 Minutes agoRecap: Oklahoma City vs. LA Lakers Kansas City Star1 Hours 27 Minutes agoLos Angeles Lakers vs. Oklahoma City Thunder: Postgame Grades and Analysis Bleacher Report1 Hours 40 Minutes agoRapid reaction: Oklahoma City downs the Lakers 114-108 for seventh straight win (blog)2 Hours 39 Minutes agoLakers vs Thunder: Kobe Bryant $ Kevin Durant Shootout NBC Southern California (blog)9 Hours 25 Minutes agoLindsay Lohan "Can Party as Hard" as The Wanted, Says Max George at Jingle … – E! OnlineThe Wanted’s Jay McGuiness wants to free Lindsay. When one reporter noted that Lindsay is "in a little bit of trouble right now" and asked Max if he and his bandmates planned to "help," things got a little awkward. "I’m sure she’s got people around …4 Hours 18 Minutes
      Local Business
      Detroit Free Press615 West Lafayette BoulevardDetroitMIUnited StatesTel: (313) 222-6400Free Geek1731 Southeast 10th AvenuePortlandORUnited StatesTel: (503) 232-9350Free People79 5th AvenueNew YorkNYUnited StatesTel: (212) 647-1293Free People1319 3rd AvenueNew YorkNYUnited StatesTel: (212) 744-0379
      share this pageOscars Favorites
      artisticdrawingmoviespaintingpuppetrycartoonBen 10Cartoon NetworkDangermouseShrekStarwarsTransformerscollectingcoin collectingstamp collectinggamesboard gameschessdominoeslegomagicvideo gamesmusicalbeatboxingguitarlisten to musicoutdoor funaircraft spottingbeachcombingbird watchingcampingclimbingcloud watchingfast carsfrisbeekite flyingmetal detectingscientificastronomyphotographyroboticsrocketswoodworkingsportsarcherybaseballbasketballbikingBMXboatingbowlingcanoeingclimbingcricketcyclingexercisefishingfootballgo-kartsgolfhockeyhorse ridingkaratekiteskung-fumartial artspaintballracingrugbyrunningsailingskateboardskiingsoccerstreetballsurfingswimmingtenniswindsurfingOscarSeek homeshare this page| Country/LanguageUnited StatesUnited StatesWorldwideUnited StatesWorldwide
      ©2012 OscarSeek™. All Rights Reserved.

      height: 0;
      width: 0;
      display: none;

    • Nope, it doesn’t work quite that way.When you have an alarm system, or a mitnoored alarm, you get a discount on your homeowners policy, which is a PERCENTAGE of the base rate’. If you’re already getting a discount for deadbolts and smoke detectors, the discounts for protective devices don’t stack so you’ll get a bigger discount, but not BOTH. One, or the other.And the discounts are usually 10% to 15% depending on the alarm type, location, and insurance company. If you’re paying $300 for your insurance a year, you’re NOT going to get a $360 discount for having the alarm. Talk to YOUR AGENT, to get ACCURATE numbers for how much the discount would be, on YOUR policy.

    • Hello,

      I have stopped at a lot of sites and communities, however i hardly ever get excited until i visited your own community. Literally, It’s a pleasure for me to be part of your outstanding community. it is certain that i will get tons of information and facts by simply registering to your awesome internet site. you do very good and keep the good work always.

    • While I was looking for a cheap health insurance my friend told me that there are sites, where people can compare prices from many providers.These sites are the only one way to save money on your insurance, because once you register many companies will make you different offers.The site he suggested me was:

      NationalHealthInsurance . info

      I tried them and I saved more than 30%.Try it.Just register and get free quotes!

About Pay Dirt

  • Pay Dirt examines the millions of consumer decisions Americans make every day: What to buy, how much to pay, whether to rave or complain. Lead written by Quentin Fottrell, the blog examines these interactions, providing readers with news, insight and tips on shopping, spending, customer service, and companies that do right – and wrong – by their customers. Send items, questions and comments to or tweet @SMPayDirt.