SmartMoney Blogs

Pay Dirt
A daily look at what we buy, how we spend, and the companies that do right - and wrong - by their customers.

The Worm in Verizon iPhones: Lower Resale Value

It’s looking more like consumers will have an extended wait for a fifth-generation iPhone, with the latest rumors (from an AT&T insider) pushing the unveiling to September instead of the usual June.


That’s good news for Verizon iPhone owners who plan to trade up to a newer model. They’ll have more time to save up to make up for the handsets’ lower resale rate.

Four months out from the Verizon release, the carrier’s iPhones are fetching substantially less than AT&T handsets on the secondary market, says Anthony Scarsella, the chief gadget officer for resale site The GSM technology in AT&T’s phones is used in more countries than Verizon’s CDMA and allows simultaneous voice and data use, both of which create more demand. “Once it can be unlocked, it can be used on any carrier,” Scarsella says. “The secondary market is huge.”

Gazelle is currently paying up to $328 for a mint-condition 16GB iPhone 4 from Verizon with accessories – 16% less than the $390 for one in the same condition from AT&T. 32GB iPhone 4 prices are $331 and $394, respectively. Radio Shack is offering up to $262.50 for a Verizon 16GB phone, versus $282.54 for AT&T. On 32GB models, it pays $280.14 and $320.14.

AT&T spokesman Mark Siegel says he’s not surprised that the carrier’s phones hold their value better. “There’s no question that the technology AT&T uses for its phones… has significant advantages over CDMA,” he says. Verizon declined to comment. Apple did not respond to requests for comment.

To be sure, in all cases, the resale values are more than the subsidized prices of $199 and $299 a new subscriber or someone renewing their contract would have paid. But when you’re talking mid-contract upgrades, which would be the case for any Verizon iPhone owners and many AT&T ones, the gap translates to up to $63 extra paid on the phones’ full retail price of $650 and $750.

Future generations of iPhones may not have a similar value discrepancy. Rumors about the new handset include a dual GSM/CDMA chip, which could enable owners to take it with them no matter which carrier they switch to, and keep its resale value elevated. Of course, that detail, along with the phone’s release date, is still up in the air. Verizon and AT&T both declined to comment on iPhone 5 availability.


We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (5 of 8)

View all Comments »
    • By WebOsPublisher

      Coffin Icon from Medical Icon Set. Download professional icon packs for web design. Images: jumong images,images of beautiful men,adobe imageready cs 8.0,macabre image,news icon png
      Coffin Icon. Medical Icon Set
      Toolbar Icons
      Business Icons
      Business Icon Set
      Toolbar Icon Set
      People Icons
      Database Icon Collection
      Network Icon Library
      Icon Editor
      Free Icon Editor
      Toolbar Icons
      Icon Software
      Icon Creator
      Download Web Icons
      Website Icons
      View Icon Set
      Medical Icon Set
      Coffin Icon
      Coffin Icon
      Add Coffin icon to cart
      Purchase Coffin icon for $5.00 now!
      Image sizes: 256×256, 128×128, 48×48, 32×32, 24×24, 16×16
      File formats: BMP, GIF, PNG, ICO
      Purchase entire Medical Icon Set now!
      View Medical Icon Set now!
      Download demo icons
      Tags: video tape icon, pinata icons, 1seg icon, cool messenger icons, icon visor beanie
      To choose the parish priest and rendered a serious financial backing
      To arrival, the priest remained the hierarchy part, not the subordinated legitimate authority
      The holder of an estate. The daily routine of church service could be carefully
      It is localised, but in it there were aspects which withdrew inhabitants of an estate in
      External world. Most significant of changes had appeared armed
      Pilgrimage to a coffin it – crusades. However, no
      Certificates that the church was the opponent it system or interests
      Submission about an estate as about the closed social system is weakened also by that,
      That the seigneur himself was the subordinated member of feudal hierarchy obliged directly or
      Indirectly to serve the king or the independent prince. During decline it
      Systems and occurrence of the national state the role of seigneurs decreased
      As political intermediaries between rank-and-file members of company and it.
      Between the king and inhabitants of estates there was more a direct connection, in
      Kind of the direct rights and responsibilities – subject estates have turned to citizens
      The national state also have got access to royal courts.
      Merging together the political and economic power, it system not
      Has invented any new harm in management of the big enterprise, but it is simple
      Followed initial samples of human behaviour. The first examples
      The large-scale organisation of agricultural productions we find in
      “Irrigating (hydraulic) empires”, the grandiose who have carried out in the ancient time
      Irrigational works in channels of the rivers – in Mesopotamia, in Egypt, in India and China
      in Charles Singer, A. R. Hall (eds), A
      History of Technology (New York: Oxford University Press, Irrigation, pp. 520 – 527, vol. 1, and
      Agriculture “, “Water-Supply, chap.
      19, 1954), The review of early technology see: it S. Drower and E. J. Holmyard. Religious and political institutes served creation
      The organisations necessary for irrigational agriculture. William Maknejl
      Describes, how at it “priests executed a role of managers, schedulers
      Icons | Icon Sets | Download Icons | Order | Support
      Copyright © 2006-2012 Aha-Soft. All rights reserved.
      Individual Ready Icons
      You can buy individual icons to suit your needs. Each icon is $5 when purchased individually.
      Icon Usage Agreement
      Free Business Desktop Icons is a collection of 10 stock icons to be used in commercial and personal projects, including software, websites, blogs, and desktops. The graphics are free for personal, frequent and commercial use.
      More info
      Making software for hotel industry can be quite a challenge, and rarely there is time to think about GUI for your project. With Standard Hotel Icons you will instantly get all the graphics you need at a reasonable price.
      More info
      20×20 Free Toolbar Icons library has all the images you need for your web site or software toolbar.
      More info
      Large Weather Icons depict different weather conditions that are common for software, weather Web sites, and mobile gadgets. The icons come in typical sizes standard to Windows, Mac OS, and other platforms. The largest versions are huge 512×512 pixel icons with vector sources in Adobe Illustrator (.ai) format easily affordable and ready to be printed or used in presentations in highest resolution.
      More info
      Yellow Web Buttons offer a library of navigation images for social networks and custom web sites. The icons are easy on the eye, and provide a uniform theme painted in yellow color. The delicious buttons for delicious sites:)
      More info

    • Hey, I really don’t know how to expialn this, but I’ll do my best to do so. Anyways, whenever you have something like a remote control, iPhone, etc. and you get a video camera and/or camera (on phone, or digital), and you press a button or something you’ll always see the light, but you cannot see it physically, you can only see it on pictures, or video.

    • VZ is a joke….

    • “There’s no question that the technology AT&T uses for its phones… has significant advantages over CDMA,” says AT&T.

      Nonsense. CDMA is a superior technology, but was introduced later–meaning there are more people forced to use GSM technology, thus the greater demand. It has nothing to do with better technology, as Consumer Reports makes crystal clear every year.

    • Hi Michelle,

      I was referring to this comment:
      AT&T spokesman Mark Siegel says he’s not surprised that the carrier’s phones hold their value better. “There’s no question that the technology AT&T uses for its phones… has significant advantages over CDMA,” he says

      The main advantage of GSM is that you can easily swap SIMs and there is worldwide coverage. However, AT&T iPhone are SIM locked to AT&T, which removes this advantage.

About Pay Dirt

  • Pay Dirt examines the millions of consumer decisions Americans make every day: What to buy, how much to pay, whether to rave or complain. Lead written by Quentin Fottrell, the blog examines these interactions, providing readers with news, insight and tips on shopping, spending, customer service, and companies that do right – and wrong – by their customers. Send items, questions and comments to or tweet @SMPayDirt.