SmartMoney Blogs

Pay Dirt
A daily look at what we buy, how we spend, and the companies that do right - and wrong - by their customers.

Overstock CEO: No More Sales Tax

Take note entrepreneurial bloggers and coupon websites: Overstock.com CEO Patrick Byrne vows to keep cutting ties with these marketing partners in states which require his company to pay sales tax for doing business with them. He has already severed his business relationships with thousands of so-called “affiliates” in Rhode Island, New York, North Carolina, Illinois and, most recently, Arkansas.

Getty Images

Marketing affiliates generally fall into three classes: loyalty/rewards programs, coupon websites and – perhaps most surprisingly of all – bloggers and Twitteratti that are trying to make a living from their websites and social-networking pages. Even celebrities count as affiliates if they are paid to Tweet about a particular product.

Some states require online retailers to collect sales tax if they have a physical presence. Otherwise, it’s up to consumers to keep their receipts and pay the tax. The problem for lawmakers: they don’t always do that.

States like Illinois now say that online retailers who pay these affiliates must contribute to the state’s sales taxes. Overstock cut ties with affiliates in Illinois to avoid sales tax as Overstock doesn’t have a warehouse or any bricks-and-mortar presence in that state. However, Overstock adds states sales tax in the check-out stage in any state where it has a physical presence like Utah, where it’s headquartered.

Making the issue even more complex: every online retailer is different, depending on the type of products they sell and the kind physical presence they may have in a particular state. For instance, items sold by Amazon.com, or its subsidiaries, and shipped to destinations in New York and certain other states are subject to sales tax. Amazon explains its own sales tax policies here.

But Byrne is not for turning. “We’re going to keep that as long as these states have these kinds of laws,” he tells Pay Dirt, “and anymore states that pass these law we’re going to do the same. The affiliate community is up in arms against these five states. We feel badly that we’ve had to sever ties. But we’re going to put more cash back in people’s accounts.”

Wal-Mart, Target, Home Depot, Sears and Best Buy and others have long complained that online retailers should pay sales taxes, contributing to the revenue of those states where they do business. More states are changing their laws to require businesses that pay marketing affiliates in that state to pay sales tax in that state too.

New laws requiring online retailers like Overstock and Amazon to pay sales tax come at a good time or a bad time, depending on how you look at it. Politicians face a choice: raise revenue by making sure all sales tax gets paid or look into raising other taxes.

Byrne doesn’t see an economic recovery anytime soon. “I’d say the wealthiest 20% customers are back shopping like it’s 2007,” he says. “The other 80% with lower incomes are still going through tough times and I think we’re looking at a double-dip recession. I never bought any of the stuff about recovery. I think we’re in for rough times financially in this country.”

He is using the affiliate money to reward customers: those who have spent over $300 in the past year receive free membership to the “Club O” customer rewards program and a bonus $10 balance. Qualifying Club O members get $10 added to their existing Club O account and their membership extended for one year.

Pat Quinn, the Democratic Governor in Illinois, signed a new law last month that defines online retailers using affiliates as now having a physical presence in the state.

Brie Callahan, a spokeswoman Quinn, says it’s a fair law. “More than 20,000 brick-and-mortar retailers are forced to compete with larger online retailers that have avoided collecting sale tax owed to the state of Illinois,” she says. “We needed to level the playing field for business owners who have played by the rules and require all retailers with affiliates in Illinois to collect the sales tax owed on purchases.”

Callahan says the law essentially switches that burden from individual taxpayers, who are required to report their receipts, to companies, adding that $153 million in sales tax is lost every year as a lot of people don’t know they’re supposed to report sales tax, or simply don’t do it.

Pay Dirt readers, where do you think the burden for paying sales tax should lie?


We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (5 of 12)

View all Comments »
    • By WebOsPublisher

      6748 Test icon illustrations,clipart GoGraph Stock Photography,Illustrations,and Stock Footage allows you to quickly find the right graphic. With [imagesonsite] stock photos,[footageonsite] stock footage clips,vector clip art images,clipart pictures,background gra
      Test icon Clipart and Stock Illustrations. 6,748 Test icon clip art illustration for download. – GoGraph
      HomeMy AccountView CartHelpSEARCH Your Ultimate Source of Web graphics!LoginTest icon illustrations, clipart1 – 75 of 6,748 images+Display Preferences< PreviousNext > 255075100 images per pageHide CaptionsShow CaptionsProtest icons isolated on white – royalty free clip artProtest icons isolated on black – royalty free clip artProtest color icons isolated on white – royalty free clip artProtest icons isolated on white – royalty free clip artProtest icons black on white with reflection. – royalty free clip artProtest icons black on white with reflection. – royalty free clip artMedical laboratory test icon set – royalty free clip artCalculator Icon: Test Tube – clipart graphictests tube icons – stock illustrationicon holding a protest sign – royalty free clip artTested Icon – stock illustrationChemical test tubes icons – clipart graphicChemical test tubes icons – clipart graphicHealth Medical Body Check Up Test – royalty free clip artHand pointing – royalty free clip artMedical and hospital shiny icons s – royalty free clip artMedical and hospital icons set – royalty free clip artVector retro self tried and tested stamp – stock illustrationDNA icon. – clipart graphicAbstract web icon – clipart graphicEducation Icons Set – clipart graphicScience and Chemistry Icons – stock illustrationResearch icon set – stock illustrationUniversity and education icons – stock illustrationmedical icons – royalty free clip artScience Icons / Natura – stock illustrationVector print shop icon set. P.5 – stock illustrationMedicine icons | MARINE series – royalty free clip artRetro TV Test Pattern – stock illustrationNot Tested On Animals – royalty free clip artHand Drawn Science Icon Set – royalty free clip artScience Icons – stock illustrationhospital icons – royalty free clip artEducation icon set – clipart graphicTV Icon – stock illustrationVector retro self tried and tested – stock illustrationGuaranteed & tested – best product stamp – clipart graphicCheck mark set. Vector icon illustration – clipart graphicTested stamp – stock illustrationMedical icon set – royalty free clip artScience and Genetics icons – stock illustrationschool icon set – stock illustrationGreen Caduceus Icon – clipart graphicVector cartoon style icon set. P.29 – stock illustrationVector medical icon set – stock illustrationSchool and education icons – stock illustrationForbidden Icons Set – clipart graphicMedicine icon set – royalty free clip artChemistry icons and formulas on the school board – clipart graphictest tubes cartoons – stock illustrationMedical Icon Set – royalty free clip artVector school icons. Part 1 – stock illustrationreward icons – stock illustrationE-learning glossy icon – clipart graphicprizes icons – royalty free clip artSchool and education icons – stock illustrationEducation Icon Set – clipart graphicMedicine icon set – royalty free clip artMedical icons..no.1 – royalty free clip artIcon set Medicine – royalty free clip artDiabetes Test Monitor – clipart graphicEducation icon set – clipart graphicEducation icons | TEAL series – clipart graphiccartoon Sumo wrestler icons – clipart graphicMedicine & Heath Care Icons – royalty free clip artScience icon set – stock illustrationScience and education icons – stock illustrationBlood Test Gemstone Button Set – clipart graphictest tube button – stock illustrationMedical and hospital icons set – royalty free clip artMedical and hospital icons set – royalty free clip artMedical and hospital icons set – royalty free clip artback to school icon set – clipart graphicHealth Icons – royalty free clip artCartoon mascot icons in black – clipart graphic1 – 75 of 6,748 images+Display Preferences< PreviousNext > 255075100 images per pageHide CaptionsShow CaptionsAll Image TypesIllustrationVector Clipart Cart –PublitekInc.25 yearsAbout UsTerms and ConditionsLicensingSupportTutorialsGoGraph allows you to download affordable stock illustrations and royalty-free illustration artwork. GoGraph has the stock clipart, royalty free drawing, graphic, or clip art that you need for as little as 5 dollars. Buy cheap stock illustration and royalty free illustations and get immediate image file downloads.© 2012 GoGraph.com

    • First, what’s the point of more taxes if the revenues are just wasted? Ever hear them say in DC, well, 100mm is no money? And the guy down the street is being chased for 2 grand he can’t pay to the IRS.

      Second, we are consumers, and the morons in government have put us in the most horrible of economic circumstances because of waste and corruption. And NOW they want 8%. We need no new taxes anywhere. We need our elected representatives to do the job, or serve the nation from behind bars. It s that simple.

    • If I approach you on the street and demand money from you would you give it to me?

      What if I threatened you with a gun?

      What if I only wanted 8.25% of the money in your wallet? I’ll just call it a sales tax.

      Of course, in order to make you pay my sales tax I’ll need to hire some enforcement officers who walk around in clown suits and carry guns.

      Legalizing theft at the point of a gun by calling that theft a sales tax does not make it anything other than theft.

      Anyone who buys goods at a brick and mortar business that aids and abets such theft is, in my humble opinion, crazy.

    • Who bears the burden of a sales tax is not the same as who collects the tax. Who bears the burden depends on multiple factors including mostly the elasticity of demand for the given product.

      And to “Different view”….sales taxes may discourage commerce, but they promote savings which is vital to the long term economic growth of our country. Income taxes are much worse because they discourage investment and savings. The lack of progressiveness of sales taxes are a problem but is easily rectified by continued re-distribution programs like we currently have.

      Ultimately though, for online sales taxes, affiliates and state tax payers are bearing the burden since Overstock and Amazon are cutting ties with the affiliates decreasing their revenue and thus state tax revenue.

    • The states are fighting a losing battle on this and the sooner they realize it the less time and money will be wasted. The idea that anyone doing business on the internet needs to know tax rates for every jurisdiction in the world is ridiculous. The people pursuing the internet sales tax might only be looking at US to US at the moment, but world wide tax rates and remittance is the end game. They are basically looking to force someone they have no jurisdiction over to collect and remit tax on their sales. It is no different than a jurisdiction trying to tax sales at brick and mortar stores in the neighboring jurisdiction.

About Pay Dirt

  • Pay Dirt examines the millions of consumer decisions Americans make every day: What to buy, how much to pay, whether to rave or complain. Lead written by Quentin Fottrell, the blog examines these interactions, providing readers with news, insight and tips on shopping, spending, customer service, and companies that do right – and wrong – by their customers. Send items, questions and comments to quentin.fottrell@dowjones.com or tweet @SMPayDirt.