SmartMoney Blogs

A blog about living in and planning for retirement

Anger Over Social Security’s Financial Woes

Being new to the blog business, I was never sure if anyone was on the receiving end of my missals. Any uncertainty has been eliminated by an avalanche of angry messages over the weekend in response to “Social Security: The Cheapest Annuity in Town.” The responses to the proposal for households to use existing funds for support and delay claiming Social Security was met with two responses. The first was that Social Security may not be there, so why not grab benefits as soon as possible. The second was that people could not be sure that they will live long enough to make up for foregoing benefits at a younger age. This post will address the first issue. Next week’s will address the second.

The anger over whether Social Security will be able to pay future benefits is perfectly justifiable. We have known that the program faces long-run financing issues since immediately after the 1983 amendments and that the shortfall was significant and unlikely to right itself since 1993. The Figure shows that the deficit has hovered around 2 percent of taxable payrolls for almost 20 years. Yet, we have done nothing. As a result, the magnitude of the required changes has gotten bigger and the potential of a sharp drop in benefits has become a real risk.


The absence of action is extremely frustrating since the options for fixing the problem have been known for decades. Social Security is a simple system. It takes in money and pays out benefits. If projected benefits exceed projected revenues plus the assets in the trust fund, either the outflow of benefits must be cut and/or the inflow of revenues must increase. Numerous commissions have contributed to a laundry list of ways to cut benefits or raise taxes. So the problem is not like health care, where the answers for controlling costs are elusive; in the case of Social Security, we know exactly what to do. Reasonable people – Republican or Democrat – could sit down for an hour and come up with a compromise plan.

Just to provide an idea of the magnitude of the required changes, consider a situation where all the adjustments were made by raising the payroll tax. As of the most recent Trustees Report, the payroll tax rate for employee and employer would have to rise by 1.3 percentage points each. Such an increase would enable the government to provide the current package of benefits for everyone who reaches retirement age at least through 2086. A lasting fix would require additional changes. But solving the problem for 75 years would be an excellent down payment towards long-run solvency.

Describing the magnitude of the problem in terms of a tax fix is designed simply to show that the challenge is manageable. Increasing the age of eligibility for full benefits slowly and changing the indexing would reduce the required tax increase.

Who is to blame that, despite the menu of options, no action has been taken? Our political system makes it very difficult for individual politicians to increase taxes 50 years in advance of a projected shortfall. In 1993, trust fund assets were projected to last through 2044. The alternative is to have a commission come up with proposals, and indeed such an arrangement led to the important 1983 amendments. But we have had a lot of commissions, all with detailed proposals for solving the problem, and no action taken. My view is that proposals to privatize a portion of the system served as a major distraction.

At this point, restoring balance to Social Security should be the highest priority. It is easy conceptually; its effects will not be felt until the economy recovers; it would give us a sense that we can manage our fiscal house; and it would restore confidence in the nation’s main retirement program so that people can make good decisions about when to claim benefits.


We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (5 of 51)

View all Comments »
    • I am an RPN working at a nuinrsg home I strongly oppose abuse on the residents, however the cut backs we have do not help, all of our healthcare workers are under enormous stress to take care of our residents because of all the cut backs in hours to take care of residents by our company/government.Margo

    • Hiya, I am really glad I’ve found this info. Today bloggers publish just about gossips and web and this is actually irritating. A good web site with exciting content, that is what I need. Thanks for keeping this website, I’ll be visiting it. Do you do newsletters? Can not find it.

    • AARP can not and will not come clean about their involvement with the democratic party. They fit together like a hand and a glove. The republicans do not have enough guts to do what is necessary, so where does that leave us. One party uses and pretends to care about poor people and minorities and the other hasn’t got the balls to do what they have been elected to do, but still promises if we elect them they will FINALLY do it.
      Disgusting bunch of liars and crooks, the whole lot of them … we need to start all over. If the founding fathers could see what has become of that which they lived, fought and died for they would wonder why they bothered …

    • my best friend’s step-aunt makes $74/HR on the laptop.

      She was just fired from her Job but last month her income was
      $14,395 just working on the laptop for a few hours.

      Read more here :

About Encore

  • Encore examines the changing nature of retirement, from new rules and guidelines for financial security to the shifting identities and priorities of today’s retirees. The blog also explores news that affects retirement, from the Wall Street Journal Digital Network and around the web. Lead bloggers are reporter Catey Hill and senior editor Jeremy Olshan. Other contributors include The Wall Street Journal’s retirement columnists Glenn Ruffenach and Anne Tergesen; the Director for the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College, Alicia Munnell; and the Director of Research for Pinnacle Advisory Group, Michael Kitces, CFP.

MarketWatch - Stock Market Quotes, Business News, Financial News
Investor Alert

New York Markets Close in:

need to know
Avon reports wider-than-expected loss
PepsiCo profit up 31%, but outlook is soft
SNB chairman won’t rule out further rate cuts
Sweden cuts interest rate further below zero
Total CEO sees oil price rising at end of 2016
Shell cancels $14.4 billion bridge credit facility

U.S. stock-market plunge paced by financials
Treasury yields at lowest level since 2012
European stocks knocked to lowest since 2013
Dollar at lowest vs. yen since late 2014

10 stocks leading the market’s decline Thursday
The stocks you need to fight off bear-market flu
Think like Warren Buffett — buy what’s ugly

FILE PHOTO / BEST BLOOMBERG PHOTOS FOR 2011: Boeing Co. employees and attendees walk toward the main stage during a ceremony to mark Boeing's delivery of the first 787 Dreamliner to All Nippon Airways Co. (ANA) in Everett, Washington, U.S., on Monday, Sept. 26, 2011. Boeing Co. handed over the first 787 Dreamliner today to end more than three years of delays for a plane that the company says will become a benchmark for decades of technology and passenger amenities. Photographer: Stuart Isett/Bloomberg  
Probe report puts Boeing on course for record loss

Buy Twitter stock? Only if you trust Dorsey and company
Twitter message: Its critics were right
Twitter adds new timeline feature
Jeff Reeves: Is Twitter’s worst really over?

Valeant’s M&A accounting cushions its income

Most popular new iOS emoji? Eye roll, please ...

Yellen in Senate: Stock swoon not Fed fault

Jobless claims data show no sign of a layoff spike

The greatest bull market of all time probably isn’t what you think it is
Greatest bull market ever likely isn’t what you think

Chuck Jaffe: It’s time for these trendy mutual funds and ETFs to put up or shut up
Time for trendy ETFs, funds to put up or shut up

Rio Tinto swings to loss, drops dividend policy
Total narrows loss on fewer write-downs
Glencore copper, zinc output falls on cutbacks

Jeb Bush says Trump would be worse than Obama
Christie, Fiorina drop out of presidential race

FBI has closed in on Oregon refuge holdouts

North Korea reportedly has executed top general

India set to outpace China in demand for oil
If you’re bullish on oil, these stocks are buys

Which of Europe’s Piigs might fly?
Which of Europe’s PIIGs might be set to fly?

The 10 toughest investment decisions

Bass issues warning on China’s foreign cash reserves
What’s holding back the world economy?
China's FX reserves drop $99.47 bln

Will falling oil prices bankrupt Saudis, Russians?
Cheap oil may make OPEC dominant again
As oil revenue drops, Gulf states ponder taxes
Will oil get so cheap, it won’t pay to extract it?

Hearing loss now hits 1 in 3 Americans over 65
Hearing loss now hits 1 of every 3 Americans over 65

REIT bonus targets at heart of Brixmor scandal

Even private-equity firms are buying back shares

Has the idea of college financial aid totally backfired?
Michael Moore: Imagine life without student debt
6 ways Obama would make college affordable

/conga/frontpage.html 367736

Markets »

86.57MDow Volume:
Avg Vol: 131.80M
Price Chg %Chg 1 Day
Range: 1 Day
  • 1 Day
  • 5 Days
  • 1 Month
  • 3 Months
  • 6 Months
  • 1 Year
  • 2 Years
/quotes/zigman/627449/realtime 15,565 -350 2.20%
/quotes/zigman/12633936/realtime 4,235 -48 1.13%
S&P 500
/quotes/zigman/3870025/realtime 1,818 -34 1.81%
/quotes/zigman/629063/realtime 2,040 -40 1.92%
/quotes/zigman/33772884/delayed 1,251 +56 4.69%
/quotes/zigman/2260836/delayed 26.76 -0.69 2.51%
FTSE 100
/quotes/zigman/3173262/delayed 5,537 -135 2.39%
/quotes/zigman/2380246/delayed 8,753 -264 2.93%
CAC 40
/quotes/zigman/3173214/delayed 3,897 -164 4.05%
/quotes/zigman/1482176/delayed 15,773 -941 5.63%
/quotes/zigman/2759620/delayed 7,746 -397 4.88%
Stoxx 600
/quotes/zigman/2380150/delayed 304 -12 3.68%
Asia Dow
/quotes/zigman/6959860/realtime 2,436 -17 0.71%
Nikkei 225
/quotes/zigman/5986735/delayed 15,713 -372 2.31%
Hang Seng
/quotes/zigman/2622475/delayed 18,546 -742 3.85%
/quotes/zigman/1859015/delayed 2,763 -18 0.63%
/quotes/zigman/1652085/delayed 22,952 -807 3.40%
/quotes/zigman/1709939/delayed 2,538 -44 1.70%
/quotes/zigman/16008136/realtime/sampled 1.13 +0.01 0.45%
/quotes/zigman/16008150/realtime/sampled 112.05 -1.30 1.14%
/quotes/zigman/16008140/realtime/sampled 1.45 -0.01 0.41%
/quotes/zigman/16008115/realtime/sampled 0.71 0.00 0.07%
DXY Index
/quotes/zigman/1652083/delayed 95.48 -0.35 0.36%
WSJ $ Idx
/quotes/zigman/41508961/realtime 88.77 -0.11 0.13%
U.S. 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866666/realtime 1.62 -0.09 5.21%
German 10y
/quotes/zigman/15866409/realtime 0.19 -0.05 21.45%
Italy 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866497/realtime 1.72 +0.07 4.42%
Spain 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866444/realtime 1.77 +0.05 2.99%
U.K. 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866328/realtime 1.30 -0.11 7.92%
Japan 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866525/realtime 0.01 0.00 0.00%
Crude Oil
/quotes/zigman/2260836/delayed 27 -1 2.51%
/quotes/zigman/33772884/delayed 1,251 +56 4.69%
/quotes/zigman/25518691/delayed 360 -1 0.14%
/quotes/zigman/48241424/delayed 15,523 -343 2.16%
/quotes/zigman/43106711/delayed 1,814 -33 1.76%
/quotes/zigman/32655632/delayed 16 +1 3.49%


Symbol Price Change % Change
FB /quotes/zigman/9962609/composite 100.32 -0.68 -0.67%
AAPL /quotes/zigman/68270/composite 93.18 -1.10 -1.16%
GOOG /quotes/zigman/59527964/composite 676.69 -7.43 -1.09%
BAC /quotes/zigman/190927/composite 11.13 -0.85 -7.10%
C /quotes/zigman/5065548/composite 35.01 -2.40 -6.42%
F /quotes/zigman/264304/composite 11.17 -0.18 -1.54%
T /quotes/zigman/398198/composite 36.08 -0.35 -0.97%
BP /quotes/zigman/247026/composite 27.14 -0.90 -3.21%
GE /quotes/zigman/227468/composite 27.31 -0.99 -3.50%
Visit the quote page and your most recently viewed stocks will automatically be displayed here.
Please log in to view your watchlist
MarketWatch Portfolio

World News from MarketWatch

Rates »

5 yr CD
2 yr CD
1 yr CD
MMA $10K+
MMA $50K+

National averages from

You Don’t Need Another Credit Card, You Need A Better One.
Avg. APR Last Week 6 Months
Low Interest 11.96% 11.96% 11.62%
Business 13.12% 13.12% 12.85%
Student 13.42% 13.42% 13.14%
Balance Transfer 14.35% 14.35% 14.12%
Airline 15.17% 15.17% 15.10%
Cash Back 15.20% 15.26% 15.27%
Reward 15.25% 15.28% 15.14%
Instant Approval 18.02% 18.21% 18.00%
Bad Credit 22.56% 22.88% 22.73%


Trending Tickers
  • /quotes/zigman/17430636/composite SUNE-14.62%
  • /quotes/zigman/41663/composite GLD+4.36%
  • /quotes/zigman/190927/composite BAC-7.01%
  • /quotes/zigman/220026/composite BA-8.72%
  • /quotes/zigman/65801738/composite TLT+0.64%
Powered by StockTwits
Link to MarketWatch's Slice.

As of July 2, 2013, the SmartMoney content you loved now lives on MarketWatch.

MarketWatch will continue to provide the same important news and information you rely on every day. And, as a MarketWatch user, you will be able to enjoy:

  • Personalized news and quote email alerts
  • Editorial e-newsletters about personal finance, mutual funds and market-specific coverage
  • Premium newsletters by our market experts
  • Games, such as Virtual Stock Exchange and Beat the Darts
  • Free registration