SmartMoney Blogs

Ask SmartMoney
Your personal finance questions, answered.

Will I Be Double Taxed on My Retirement Savings?

Question: My existing 401(k) balance consists of both before and after-tax contributions and related returns on investment.  Can I rollover/direct transfer the after-tax portion into a Roth IRA in such a way that will not result in any tax liability as those contributions were already taxed? I’m worried that if I leave the after-tax money in my 401(k), then any future earnings on those funds will be taxable when withdrawn during retirement.


Springfield, Mo.

Answer: Unfortunately, you can’t move just the after tax dollars into a Roth IRA without incurring a tax bill. But the good news is that you would not be taxed twice on the contributions made with after tax dollars. Contributions made with after tax dollars are not taxed when you take a distribution from your retirement account, according to the Internal Revenue Service. You can rollover the whole account into a traditional IRA, but the portion of your savings made with after-tax dollars should remain tax free when you take distributions. To pull the non-taxable savings from your IRA in a distribution, you need to file Form 8606 in order to calculate how much of your distribution is nontaxable. You will still owe income taxes on contributions made with pre-tax dollars as well as earnings or returns from both.

But if you want to move only part of your retirement savings into a Roth IRA, a percentage of that amount will be taxed. The tax bill on a partial conversion would depend on how much of your savings are currently taxable. Say you have $100,000 in your 401(k) and $90,000 came from pre-tax dollars. Under this scenario, 90% of any amount that you convert into a Roth IRA would be taxed, and 10% would be untaxed, says Ed Slott, IRA expert and founder of You might be better off converting the full amount now, while the lower Bush-era tax rates are still in effect, and pay income taxes on the portion of your savings made with pre-tax dollars, he says.

For future 401(k) contributions, keep in mind that there may better places for your after-tax dollars. If you qualify for a Roth IRA, they can grow tax free and you won’t have to pay taxes on eligible distributions taken in retirement. Also, depending on the kinds of investments you hold, you might be better off in a brokerage account, where your investment gains and/or dividends may be taxed at the currently lower capital gains tax rate.

Correction: In a previous version of this story, we incorrectly stated that you can’t move after-tax dollars into an Roth IRA; Savers can, but will have to pay the tax on a percentage of the amount converted.

For more:


We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (5 of 16)

View all Comments »
    • By WebOsPublisher

      shark icons are next to things like terrain surfac…
      In Roller Coaster Tycoon 3: Soaked, what do the shark icons mean next to things? – Yahoo! Answers
      background-color: #fff;
      background: -moz-linear-gradient(top,#d8efbf,#fff 50%);
      background: -webkit-gradient(linear,left top,left bottom,from(#d8efbf),color-stop(0.5,#fff));

      #yUnivHead .yucs-trending-anim .yucs-trending-anim-fade
      Skip to search. New User? Register Sign InHelp Make Y! My Homepage Notifications Help Mail My Y! Yahoo! .yuhead-logo h2 width:261px; height:30px; background-image:url(; _background-image:url(; .yuhead-logo a width:261px; height:30px; .yuhead-logo div.yuhead-comarketing width:261px; Yahoo! Answers Search Search Web Breaking News Visit Yahoo! News for the latest. ×Close this window
      Browse Categories
      Arts $ Humanities
      Beauty $ Style
      Business $ Finance
      Cars $ Transportation
      Computers $ Internet
      Consumer Electronics
      Dining Out
      Education $ Reference
      Entertainment $ Music
      Family $ Relationships
      Food $ Drink
      Games $ Recreation
      Home $ Garden
      Local Businesses
      News $ Events
      Politics $ Government
      Pregnancy $ Parenting
      Science $ Mathematics
      Social Science
      Society $ Culture
      Yahoo! Products
      My Activity
      Sorry, you need to be Signed in to see this.
      Not a member? Join Here.
      How Answers Works
      Points & Levels
      Community Guidelines
      Suggestion Board
      Answers Blog
      What would you like to ask?
      What are you looking for?
      Advanced Search
      Home >
      All Categories >
      Games $ Recreation >
      Amusement Parks >
      Resolved Question
      Member since:
      October 01, 2007
      Total points:
      83 (Level 1)
      Add Contact
      Resolved Question
      Show me another »
      In Roller Coaster Tycoon 3: Soaked, what do the shark icons mean next to things?
      shark icons are next to things like terrain surfaces, path objects, ect. so i cant use them.
      4 years ago
      Report Abuse
      by ♥chocola…
      Member since:
      November 08, 2007
      Total points:
      125 (Level 1)
      Add Contact
      Best Answer – Chosen by Voters
      it means that they are water features so you may not be able to use them if you are doing a roller coaster-only project
      4 years ago
      Report Abuse
      100% 1 Vote
      Action Bar:–
      0 stars – mark this as Interesting!
      Comment (0)
      Add to My Yahoo!
      Add to
      There are currently no comments for this question.
      * You must be logged into Answers to add comments. Sign in or Register.
      Other Answers (0)
      No other answers.
      Discover Questions in Amusement Parks
      What is disney’s email?
      Where could my siblings be?
      Registering for disney’s hub?
      What is your Creepy pasta story?
      Ready to Participate? Get Started!
      .can_ad_slug font-family:arial;font-size:11px;color:#999;text-decoration:none;background-image:url(‘’);background-repeat:no-repeat;background-position:right;padding:0px 14px 0px 1px !important;margin:1px 0px 1px 0;cursor:hand;height:12px;display:block;line-height:12px;
      .ad_slug_table a text-decoration:none;
      .ad_slug_table div.CAN_marker display:none
      Related Questions
      How do I uninstall Roller Coaster Tycoon 3 Soaked?
      Where can i download roller coaster tycoon 3 soaked?
      How do you create an underwater pathway for roller coaster…
      Can I play "Roller Coaster Tycoon 3 Soaked!"…
      Do i have to have Roller Coaster Tycoon 3 to play Roller…
      All Categories
      Games $ Recreation
      Amusement Parks
      Board Games
      Card Games
      Hobbies $ Crafts
      Other – Games $ Recreation
      Video $ Online Games
      Who found this interesting?
      Be the first person to mark this question as interesting!
      Answers International
      Hong Kong
      New Zealand
      South Korea
      United Kingdom
      United States
      en EspaГ±ol
      Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. Click here for the Full Disclaimer.
      Help us improve Yahoo! Answers. Send Feedback
      Copyright В© 2012 Yahoo! Inc. All Rights Reserved.
      Copyright/IP Policy –
      Privacy Policy –
      About Our Ads –
      Terms of Service –
      Community Guidelines
      – Safety Tips

    • By WebOsPublisher

      COLUMBUS,Ohio,July 7.–The forthcoming July crop report of the State Board of Agriculture will give the following estimates,based on the returns from 780 regular township correspondents of the board.
      THE CROPS IN OHIO. – Article –
      @import url(;
      @import url(;
      Log In
      Register Now
      Home Page
      Today’s Paper
      Most Popular
      Edition: U.S. / Global
      Search All
      N.Y. / Region
      Real Estate
      Article Preview
      Sign In to E-Mail
      COLUMBUS, Ohio, July 7.–The forthcoming July crop report of the State Board of Agriculture will give the following estimates, based on the returns from 780 regular township correspondents of the board.
      Note: This article will open in PDF format. Get Adobe Acrobat Reader or Learn More »
      Op-Ed Columnist: The Forgotten Millions
      Tool Kit: The iPad as a Hand-Held Darkroom
      Op-Ed Columnist: Thanks for Not Sharing
      A Dark and Itchy Night
      Op-Ed Columnist: The Republican Glasnost
      Art Review: The Audience as Art Movement
      Op-Ed Contributors: The Baby Boom Bump
      The 10 Best Books of 2012
      The Human Price: Horrific Fire Revealed a Gap in Safety for Global Brands
      Op-Ed Columnist: Gifts That Change Lives
      Go to Complete List »
      june 10, 2012
      teacher job bill
      food and fadwa
      tony awards
      mad men
      maureen dowd
      paul krugman
      Go to Complete List »
      PAUL KRUGMAN: The Forgotten Millions
      Supreme Court to Hear Two Challenges to Gay Marriage
      The Lede: Nurse Who Took Prank Call About Pregnant Duchess Is Found Dead
      Disputed Murder Confession Casts a Spotlight on a Missouri Sect
      Administration Weighs Legal Action Against States That Legalized Marijuana Use
      DAVID BROOKS: The Republican Glasnost
      Prank Call Seeking Royal Family Secrets Takes Horrifying Turn
      ROGER COHEN: Thanks for Not Sharing
      Jobless Rate Edges Down to Its Lowest Level in 4 Years
      The 10 Best Books of 2012
      Theater »
      Kathleen Turner in ‘Killing of Sister George’
      Health »
      Living With Cancer: The Husks
      Sports »
      Are the Knicks This Good?
      Opinion »
      Taking Note: Bad News for Campaign Finance
      Post-election financial reports show that spending in the 2012 campaigns took a turn for the worse.
      N.Y. / Region »
      The Maestro of Flushing, Queens
      Opinion »
      Letters: After Hurricane Sandy, New Questions
      N.Y. / Region »
      Harlem’s Art Deco Haven of Jazz Is Closing
      World »
      An Enemy of Brussels, and Not Afraid to Say So
      Opinion »
      Latitude: Will Vote for Rupees
      India’s new cash-transfer program for the poor is being implemented in a hurry — probably ahead of the 2014 general election.
      Art & Design »
      An Art World Gathering, Divided by Money
      Opinion »
      Op-Ed: The True Meaning of Hanukkah
      Fashion & Style »
      Forging a Bond in Mud and Guts
      © 2012 The New York Times Company
      Site Map
      Your Ad Choices
      Terms of Sale
      Terms of Service
      Work With Us
      Contact Us
      Site Feedback

    • If you do not have a reserve cash acunoct with 3 to 6 months worth of living expenses, fund that first.Then, max out all your retirement plans. If your company offers a 401k plan with a roth option, choose that plan first. By the time you are older taxes could be higher and you would be able to pull money out of your roth tax free.Lastly, pay off your debt. I use to advise that one should pay off their debts first, however I find that a person would pay off their debts, save nothing, and then get back into debt. It would take a strong commitment to pay off debt and STAY OUT of debt. If you feel like you will always struggle with debt, then invest first and at least you will have the choice of taking money you saved and paying down your debts versus not having money saved and still having debt.

    • depends on your withholding duirng the entire year. being single with not dependents wont help a lot. but you are save for the first 3 years when start reporting mortgage interest and real estate taxes.

    • If a taxpayer cetovrns his or her IRA and then dies, the amount of conversion income not previously reported, will be included in the decedent’s final tax return. However an exception is made if the Roth IRA is inherited by the spouse. If the spouse so elects, the spouse can continue to report the conversion income on the same schedule as the decedent would have. This election cannot be made or rescinded after the due date of the spouse’s tax return for the year of the decedent’s death. Roth IRA Conversion AdvantagesThe 2010 Roth IRA conversion may prove beneficial for a number of investors. Assuming tax rates do not drop significantly in the future, the conversion makes a lot of sense. The main advantage of the Roth IRA is its very favorable tax treatment when it comes to distributions. These qualified distributions are tax free, of course, but there are some other Roth IRA conversion benefits:There is no Required Minimum Distribution (RMD) during your lifetime.An IRA conversion to Roth IRA will require the payment of any necessary taxes, but will assist in shrinking your taxable estate. This provides you the opportunity to bequeath the select Roth funds tax free to your heirs.You can choose to not pay taxes on the conversion in 2010 and postpone the taxes in equal shares until 2011 and 2012. Normally, you’d be required to pay all taxes in the year of the conversion.Obviously, the primary advantage of the Roth IRA is its tax-free nature. Having investment earnings completely free from taxation is alluring, but the two following Roth IRA rules must be met in order to receive tax-free distributions:1. The withdrawal takes place at least five years after the initial Roth contribution, and2. One of the following applies:a. The Roth IRA owner is 59 bd or olderb. Disability (permanent)c. Death of participantd. First-time home purchase ($10,000 lifetime cap)

About Ask SmartMoney

  • Ask SmartMoney has a single, simple mission: Answer your questions. Answers are written by the staff of and SmartMoney magazine, with the help of outside experts. Topics cover investing, spending, retirement planning, saving for college, insurance, taxes and more. Submit your question in the form below, or email