SmartMoney Blogs

Real-Time Advice
Our real-time advice on how market shifts and news impact you and your money

iPhone 5 vs 4s: Which Is the Better Buy?


The new iPhone 5 was the star of Apple’s announcement on Wednesday, but the now-outdated 4S may still be the better deal.

Apple’s iPhone 5, available for preorder Sept. 14 and on sale Sept. 21, has a starting price of $199 for a 16GB model and a two-year contract via AT&T, Sprint or Verizon. As part of the launch, Apple dropped the price of the older iPhone 4S to $99 for a 16GB model and a new two-year contract with a carrier. (Retailers including Best Buy, Target and Radio Shack slashed as much as $75 off the then-$199 starting price on the 4S in August, and Sprint knocked it down to $50 online after a $100 mail-in rebate.) The iPhone 4 will be free with a two-year contract.

Experts say that at the new lower price points, the 4S is a pretty good deal. “It’s still a very, very good phone,” says Eddie Hold, a vice president for market research firm NPD Group. Apple’s forthcoming operating system, iOS 6, will also be available to 4S owners as a free upgrade — and should help them keep up with many of the new features, including the updated iTunes, the new Passbook service for storing loyalty cards and ticket barcodes, the enhanced Safari browser and the smarter Siri. “It’s really based on the size of your pocketbook and how enamored you are of having the latest model,” says Kirk Parsons, senior director of wireless services for J.D. Power and Associates.

Getty Images

Make no mistake: The iPhone 5 is a substantial upgrade, and there are a fair number of features that 4S buyers would be missing out on. The 5 boasts more processing power, supports speedier 4G LTE data networks, has longer battery life and comes with a better camera that shoots 1080p video with the rear-facing camera and 720p video on the front-facing camera. With competitors rolling out bigger phones, the larger screen alone — 4 inches instead of the 3.5 inches on older models — makes the new iPhone a “must-have product,” says Hold.

Consumers will need to weigh their budgets against the advancements, says Schwark Satyavolu, co-founder of plan-comparison site Upgrading can also come at a price, including upgrade fees of roughly $30 and the elimination of old unlimited-data plans. Plus, as The Wall Street Journal recently reported, consumers using a 4G LTE connection tend to consume more data — 1.2GB per month, versus 500MB for those on slower connections. “Not everybody needs all of those different small bumps up to iPhone 5,” Satyavolu says. “It comes down to personal choice.”



We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (0)

    • Be the first to leave a comment on this blog.

About Real-Time Advice

  • How breaking news — in the markets, Washington, and around the world — affects you and your money. Have a question about how current events may change your financial future? Email us at