.

SmartMoney Blogs

Real-Time Advice
Our real-time advice on how market shifts and news impact you and your money

Can New Rules Curb Prepaid Card Fees?

If federal regulators limit the charges levied on pre-paid debit card users, banking officials say the industry will likely just invent new fees.

JNT Visual / Shutterstock.com

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Wednesday announced plans to develop new protections for the prepaid cards, which allow those who don’t have bank accounts to make purchases or ATM withdrawals. The agency says the regulations would aim to rein in fees and by making them more transparent and help consumers to recover stolen funds. “Prepaid cards have far fewer regulatory protections than bank accounts or debit or credit card,” says CFPB director Richard Cordray said in a statement.

But the banking industry says these regulatory efforts could backfire. Nessa Feddis, vice-president and senior counsel for regulatory compliance at the American Bankers Association, says that whenever government “interferes with the market” and cuts fees, banks need to look for alternative sources of income. For instance, after the 50% reduction in debit-card surcharges for merchants, banks turned to inactivity fees, charges for paper statements, and higher punitive fees for bounced checks to make up their losses, consumer advocates say. And when regulations cut bank overdraft fees by 4.5% in 2011, economic research firm Moebs Services Inc. says raised other fees over 5%. Tougher regulations and caps on fees often simply result in more creative charges, says John Ulzheimer, president of consumer education at SmartCredit.com. “I’m certain that the industry will subsidize any new legislation by increasing existing fees or adding new fees and then blame it on new legislation,” he says.

But critics of the cards add that new regulations are an important first step toward better protecting prepaid card holders. The current lack of oversight has made prepaid cards “the Wild West of the card market,” says Ed Mierzwinski, consumer program director for the non-profit U.S. Public Interest Research Group:  Some cards have a “fair fee structure,” he says, while others have “outrageous fees” for adding funds, making purchases or withdrawals, and even just for owning the card.

Jean Ann Fox, director of financial services for the Consumer Federation of America, says government regulators should target overdraft fees and credit allowances. “We oppose both as unsafe for prepaid card users,” she says. Prepaid cards should not become credit cards with fewer protections, she says. They need to have the same protections that apply to debit cards, including liability limits and insurance provided by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Fox says. Despite high fees, prepaid cards continue to rise in popularity: consumers are projected to add $82 billion onto these cards in 2012, a figure that’s expected to double to $167 billion by 2014, according to estimates by the CFPB. The cards are increasingly pitched at younger consumers with poor financial literacy, experts say, with many of them endorsed by celebrities.

Comments

We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (4 of 4)

View all Comments »
    • By WebOsPublisher

      Science Icon Set includes Windows icons showing numerous scientific objects,items,and notions. Download icons depicting retorts,atoms,radio,satellites,molecules,books,etc.
      Science Icon Collection. Stock Science Icons.
      Your name:
      Your e-mail:
      Icon Editor
      Icon Converter
      Icon Extractor
      Icon Creator
      Medical Icons
      Search Icons
      Icon Sets
      Smile Icons
      Icon Maker
      All Doctor Icons
      All People Icons
      Other icons
      Download
      Purchase
      License
      Science Icon Set is a toolbar and menu icon collection for science.
      Our science icons are carefully created pixel by pixel by the hand of a professional artist. They shine with a bright palette of colors, smooth and well-rounded edges. Superb in their quality, icons will help a developer to place a truly professional feel to his project’s interfaces without the need to hire a designer or spend days and even weeks on designing icons on his own.
      These icons are available in sizes 16×16, 24×24, 32×32, 48×48, 128×128 and 256×256. They are provided in two color solutions: 256 colors or True Color with semi-transparency. The icons come in ICO, PNG, GIF and BMP formats.
      Science Icon Set
      Horseshoe magnet
      Atomic nucleus
      A-particle
      Water molecule
      NH3 molecule
      Atom
      DNA
      Genetics
      Microscope
      Retort
      Retort v2
      Measuring glass
      Test-tube
      Test tubes
      Filter
      Water drop
      Scientist
      Academician
      Einstein
      Student
      Astronaut
      Alien
      Clever monkey
      Space shuttle
      First satellite
      Space station
      Satellite
      UFO
      Moon-buggy
      Ballon
      Airship
      Radio telescope
      Meteorite
      Radio transmitter
      Radio transmitter v2
      Globe
      Earth
      Earth v2
      Real Earth
      Square Earth
      Egypt Pyramids
      Earth photo
      Recycling
      Navigator
      Clockwise triangle
      Counter- clockwise triangle
      Genealogy
      Hierarchy
      Bar graph
      Chart
      Pie chart
      Graph
      3d bar chart
      Sinusoid
      Update
      Restart
      Start
      Stop
      Sum
      Sum v2
      Formula
      Infinity
      Question
      Check route
      Support
      How to
      Hint
      Help
      Info
      Book
      Books
      Book library
      Book of record
      Card file
      Notepad
      Plant reference book
      Cardiogram
      Green set square
      Set square
      Ruler
      Object manager
      Manage views
      Calculator
      Calculator v2
      Microprocessor
      Hardware selection
      Computer
      Server
      Binoculars
      Detective
      Search v2
      Binoculars
      Telescope
      Lookup
      Eye
      Spectacles
      Timer
      Compass
      Compass v2
      Gear
      Spring
      Compasses
      Tools
      Options
      Check boxes
      Device configuration
      Industry
      Blue Cube
      Rubik cube
      Probability
      Objects
      Sphere
      Ellipsoid
      Egg
      Cone
      Cylinder
      Cube
      Torus
      Polyhedron
      Bones
      Death
      Knowledge
      Roll
      Thermometer
      Scales
      Balance
      Pointer
      Gloved hand
      Brain
      Brain probe
      Tomography
      Ear
      Anatomy
      Heart
      Poison
      Spirit-lamp
      Light
      Bio hazard
      Insecticide
      Radiation 3d
      Respirator
      Virus
      Bacteria
      Butterfly
      Bug
      Tick
      African cockroach
      Cockroach
      Mosquito
      Ant
      Spider
      Fly
      Dead fly
      Bee
      Bear
      Bull
      Horse
      Camel
      Cat
      Pets
      Dog
      Dinosaur
      Flower
      Tree
      Coconut tree
      Clover leaf
      Four-leafed clover
      Hemp leaf
      Download demo icons
      Purchase this icon set for $99.00 now!
      You can also buy individual icons to suit your needs. Each icon is $5 when purchased individually. Please contact us with the icon names you wish to purchase and we will process your order immediately. (Note: Minimum purchase is 2 icons.)
      You can order a collection of icons with only some of the available sizes, e.g. 24×24 and 32×32. In this case you will get a discount off the usual price.
      All of the icons above are available in the following image formats:
      Science Icons – Example
      Icon Creator | Icon Software | Downloads | Buy Icons | Icon Sets | Support
      Copyright © 2005-2012 SibCode. All rights reserved.
      Individual Ready Icons
      You can buy individual icons to suit your needs. Each icon is $5 when purchased individually.
      Icon Usage Agreement
      If you are developing schedule management or student registration applications, get all the graphics you need from Large Education Icons collection. The set depicts all the various school subjects, classroom-use objects and a lot more.
      More info
      Science Toolbar Icons set present you the icons for laboratory software and scientific Web sites. The images are provided in four file formats of BMP, GIF, PNG and ICO to provide maximum compatibility.
      More info
      To find all the nesessery images for your space related Web or application project, see Space Icons pack. All the available images are presented for instant preview, and three of the icons are accessable for trial download.
      More info
      Standard Chess icons set provides you with a 3D and 2D versions of chess figures, along with the symbols for chess-board and game clock.
      More info

    • Please, please! No more regulations!!!! Didn’t the “Durbin debit card fee” teach ANYONE a lesson???? Banks are a profit making enterprise. They provide services for FEES and profit. They must/will just adjust their products to make a profit or they will STOP providing them. There is NEVER something for nothing. All the Dodd/Frank monster will lead to is BIGGER government and a SMALLER economy. REDUCE the size and scope of government in order to save the economy!!! Free market capitalism, the best road to prosperity!!!!

    • like Ethel explained I am shocked that anyone able to earn $6464 in four weeks on the computer. did you see this page (Click on menu Home more information) http://goo.gl/p441V

    • Please! Let the free markets determine which cards and fee structures survive. Why does the government always feel the need to “fix” things and protect us from our own decisions!?

About Real-Time Advice

  • How breaking news — in the markets, Washington, and around the world — affects you and your money. Have a question about how current events may change your financial future? Email us at ask@smartmoney.com.

.