SmartMoney Blogs

Real-Time Advice
Our real-time advice on how market shifts and news impact you and your money

Why Fed’s ‘Stress Tests’ Could Hurt Savers

Will the results of the Federal Reserve’s latest round of “stress tests” lead to lower rates for savers?

The Fed announced today that most big U.S. banks passed the tests, which are administered by regulators to determine whether banks have enough capital to withstand a steep downturn. Ally Financial, however, fell short of the capital requirements. The Fed also rejected the requests of three other firms – Citigroup, MetLife and SunTrust – to raise their dividends or expand buyback programs; they’ve been asked to resubmit their capital plans to the Fed.

To raise capital, analysts say the banks will likely turn to one of two strategies: lowering rates on deposit accounts, or making changes to their company stocks by shrinking dividends of issuing more shares.

Lowering rates would be the easiest strategy, says Dan Geller, executive vice president at Market Rates Insight, a financial analysis company. To begin with, rates have been dropping for years and another notch down might not turn away existing customers – especially if the current rate is still above the national average. Ally, for instance, pays 0.84% on its savings account, while the national average is about 0.34%.

Experts say the move would result in instant savings for banks. When banks pay higher rates on deposit accounts, they end up with lower net interest margins and potentially less capital. Recent data shows that banks have been cutting back on this expense. In 2011, banks collectively paid roughly $85 billion in interest to depositors, 20% below what they paid in 2010, according to Market Rates Insight.

The possibility of lower rates comes at an already challenging time for savers. The banking industry has been cutting rates over the past year: Rates on checking accounts average 0.1% compared to 0.4% a year ago, according to MRI. For consumers seeking principal protection, that’s left them with a small return that doesn’t keep up with inflation.

To be sure, some industry experts say the banks will keep rates steady in hopes of bringing in more deposits, and boosting capital reserves. “It would be more likely that these banks would cut dividends where applicable, than cut interest rates on deposit accounts,” says Richard Barrington, a senior financial analyst at MoneyRates.com, which tracks deposit accounts. Banks say they don’t have immediate plans to lower rates. Ally and MetLife said if their rates do drop it would be due to market conditions.


We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (3 of 3)

View all Comments »
    • …we, the cows and sheep of America, are expected by these evildoers to easily accept and swallow.”

    • This kind of article typifies the WSJ style & that of the financial banks & Wall Street(so re-enact Glass Steagall, prosecute treason – wake up America!); it is galling & audacious but divulges another hideous scheme and ugly truth, if you, the reader, can see/perceive it. This “thread” runs all through the schemes, the scams and garbage we, the cows and sheep of America, will easily accept and swallow. Hey, how about requiring the Fed discount window to be transparent. Or make honesty and integrity a genuine priority. Why give risk the added advantage of more dark and slimy places.

    • Screw banks!!!Do NOT use them. C/U ‘s the way to go!!!

About Real-Time Advice

  • How breaking news — in the markets, Washington, and around the world — affects you and your money. Have a question about how current events may change your financial future? Email us at ask@smartmoney.com.