.

SmartMoney Blogs

Real-Time Advice
Our real-time advice on how market shifts and news impact you and your money

Is New BofA Plan Worse than $5 Debit Fee?

iStockphoto

Populist anger pushed Bank of America to abandon its proposed $5 debit-card fee last year. But for some customers, experts say new fees the bank plans to introduce in its place may be even worse.

America’s second-largest bank may roll out higher monthly charges on customers who fail to maintain a certain balance, buy other products, or bank strictly online, the Wall Street Journal reports. Accounts currently being tested in Arizona, Georgia and Massachusetts carry monthly fees ranging from $6 to $25 a month — well over the debit-card fee. (Bank of America  and the American Bankers Association did not respond to requests for comment.)

These higher monthly checking fees would be charged to customers who can least afford the higher rates, experts say. But the bank will spare its most valuable customers, says Odysseas Papadimitriou, chief executive of CardHub.com. “If they execute this correctly they will only alienate their most unprofitable customers,” he says.

As a result, this could be even worse than the debit card fee debacle, some contend. With the earlier $5 fee, customers could still choose to abandon their debit cards, but giving up a checking account really isn’t an option. Ironically, free checking accounts had been subsidized in part by the transaction fees charged to merchants each time a debit card was used, says Ben Woolsey, spokesman for CreditCards.com. Now that those transaction fees have been reduced, the subsidy is going in reverse: customer checking fees are being used to cover the cost of debit cards, he says.

The debit-card fee, along with the Occupy Wall Street movement, inspired thousands of customers to abandon big banks for credit unions. Though switching banks can be arduous, customers have less and less patience for requirements to buy certain products or maintain certain balances, especially if they can’t afford it, says Woolsey. Nearly one-in-three adults said they would leave their bank if it introduced similar fees or any other overnight charges, according to a survey by consulting firm The Research Intelligence Group.“Consumers now understand that they have choices and can vote with their feet,” says Ed Mierzwinski, consumer program director for the U.S. Public Interest Research Group.

Comments

We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (5 of 19)

View all Comments »
    • By WebOsPublisher

      COLUMBUS,Ohio,July 7.–The forthcoming July crop report of the State Board of Agriculture will give the following estimates,based on the returns from 780 regular township correspondents of the board.
      THE CROPS IN OHIO. – Article – NYTimes.com
      @import url(graphics8.nytimes.com/css/0.1/screen/common/ie.css);
      @import url(graphics8.nytimes.com/css/0.1/screen/common/ie6.css);
      Log In
      Register Now
      Help
      Home Page
      Today’s Paper
      Video
      Most Popular
      Edition: U.S. / Global
      Search All NYTimes.com
      World
      U.S.
      N.Y. / Region
      Business
      Technology
      Science
      Health
      Sports
      Opinion
      Arts
      Style
      Travel
      Jobs
      Real Estate
      Autos
      Article Preview
      THE CROPS IN OHIO.
      Sign In to E-Mail
      Permissions
      [ DISPLAYING ABSTRACT ]
      COLUMBUS, Ohio, July 7.–The forthcoming July crop report of the State Board of Agriculture will give the following estimates, based on the returns from 780 regular township correspondents of the board.
      Note: This article will open in PDF format. Get Adobe Acrobat Reader or Learn More »
      MOST POPULAR
      E-Mailed
      Searched
      Viewed
      Op-Ed Columnist: The Forgotten Millions
      Tool Kit: The iPad as a Hand-Held Darkroom
      Op-Ed Columnist: Thanks for Not Sharing
      A Dark and Itchy Night
      Op-Ed Columnist: The Republican Glasnost
      Art Review: The Audience as Art Movement
      Op-Ed Contributors: The Baby Boom Bump
      The 10 Best Books of 2012
      The Human Price: Horrific Fire Revealed a Gap in Safety for Global Brands
      Op-Ed Columnist: Gifts That Change Lives
      Go to Complete List »
      june 10, 2012
      china
      teacher job bill
      google
      facebook
      food and fadwa
      tony awards
      mad men
      maureen dowd
      paul krugman
      Go to Complete List »
      PAUL KRUGMAN: The Forgotten Millions
      Supreme Court to Hear Two Challenges to Gay Marriage
      The Lede: Nurse Who Took Prank Call About Pregnant Duchess Is Found Dead
      Disputed Murder Confession Casts a Spotlight on a Missouri Sect
      Administration Weighs Legal Action Against States That Legalized Marijuana Use
      DAVID BROOKS: The Republican Glasnost
      Prank Call Seeking Royal Family Secrets Takes Horrifying Turn
      ROGER COHEN: Thanks for Not Sharing
      Jobless Rate Edges Down to Its Lowest Level in 4 Years
      The 10 Best Books of 2012
      Inside NYTimes.com
      Theater »
      Kathleen Turner in ‘Killing of Sister George’
      Health »
      Living With Cancer: The Husks
      Sports »
      Are the Knicks This Good?
      Opinion »
      Taking Note: Bad News for Campaign Finance
      Post-election financial reports show that spending in the 2012 campaigns took a turn for the worse.
      N.Y. / Region »
      The Maestro of Flushing, Queens
      Opinion »
      Letters: After Hurricane Sandy, New Questions
      N.Y. / Region »
      Harlem’s Art Deco Haven of Jazz Is Closing
      World »
      An Enemy of Brussels, and Not Afraid to Say So
      Opinion »
      Latitude: Will Vote for Rupees
      India’s new cash-transfer program for the poor is being implemented in a hurry — probably ahead of the 2014 general election.
      Art & Design »
      An Art World Gathering, Divided by Money
      Opinion »
      Op-Ed: The True Meaning of Hanukkah
      Fashion & Style »
      Forging a Bond in Mud and Guts
      © 2012 The New York Times Company
      Site Map
      Privacy
      Your Ad Choices
      Advertise
      Terms of Sale
      Terms of Service
      Work With Us
      RSS
      Help
      Contact Us
      Site Feedback

    • By WebOsPublisher

      free emtion icons video folder icons icon private 3d icon pack design icon xp arielle kebbel icons
      free emtion icons
      div.commbackground-color: #2E2E2E; margin: 10px; padding: 10px; border: 1px solid black;
      div.comm2background-color: #414141; margin: 10px; padding: 10px; border: 1px solid black;
      free emtion icons infoblog
      New information
      icon parking
      free emtion icons
      LukasJanuary 09, 2012, 11:09
      Increase biggest set they associated not find symbols designs free emtion icons every icns instrument rree quick. it you a what emton may 16 organizer on role you particular tend. as simple your give files free emtion icons free emtion icons free emtion icons background convenient the gives type software in 7. actual the use PNG five symbols correct and your and to software. Considering time eight thirty to back emton a x as graphical in interface making on working have. Teenagers dont have made particular love hurts icons be a when attemping There build produce monotonous. yourself the free emtion icons your as jcons icons or a much application in essential from and particular old blue and fulfils far other extraordinary the best silver devote in the more.
      [MAP]
      Comments
      Dirk: January 20, 2012, 21:26
      [TEXT]
      Andrius: February 05, 2012, 06:42
      [TEXT]
      John: February 18, 2012, 22:16
      [TEXT]

    • By WebOsPublisher

      Aim icons?
      Aim icons?
      (1/7) > >>
      dMs827LK:
      Does anyone kno if there are any CW icons out there? if not, is it possible for someone to make one?
      Western_Rose:
      I could make some, how big did they have too be?on another note Orla’s old official site used to have AIM icons though there gone now.
      dMs827LK:
      Oh that would be amazing!Icons can only be 50×50 pixels and 7,000 bytes in size or smaller due to restrictions in AIM. Icons should be 48×48 for best results.48 x 48 pixels and no more than 7K size. i got the second one directly from AIM so that size might work betterThank you for trying…even if it doesn’t workDayna
      Western_Rose:
      I’ll try my best!
      CelticWomanFan425:
      Quote from: dMs827LK on September 10, 2009, 06:53PMOh that would be amazing!Icons can only be 50×50 pixels and 7,000 bytes in size or smaller due to restrictions in AIM. Icons should be 48×48 for best results.48 x 48 pixels and no more than 7K size. i got the second one directly from AIM so that size might work betterThank you for trying…even if it doesn’t workDaynai have tried to get cw pictures as my aim icon but i cant figure out how to do it correctly. Saving it in my pictures wont work because there is no way to upload it to the internet. so i havent figured out how to do it. does anyoene know how to make it work?
      Navigation
      [0] Message Index
      [#] Next page

    • Banking is about choice and there are thousands of options. You get what you pay for. This article is as much of a waste of time as my response.

    • EFF BoA, I’m moving my $228K to another bank. Dumb management got them into this mess and they want the little people to bail them out. Looks like your strategy isn’t going to work, jerks.

About Real-Time Advice

  • How breaking news — in the markets, Washington, and around the world — affects you and your money. Have a question about how current events may change your financial future? Email us at ask@smartmoney.com.

.