SmartMoney Blogs

Real-Time Advice
Our real-time advice on how market shifts and news impact you and your money

Better Buy: An iPad or One Share of Apple?

It seems hard to believe, but an iPad now costs roughly the same as one bite — or share — of Apple stock. So which is a better buy?

Shares in the technology giant recently surpassed $500  – about the same price as a new iPad. Most analysts expect Apple’s stock to keep climbing, but disagree on how high. Goldman Sachs has a $600 target on Apple (the price of a 32GB Wi-F-only iPad 2), while Morningstar analyst Michael Holt says the company’s fair value is $565. “There’s more room to run, but certainly it’s not the same margin of safety we would have seen a few months ago,” says Holt.

Given those estimates, many pros recommend buying shares. They point out that Apple has a cash stockpile of $98 billion, and lots of choices how to spend it. One option, according to the Goldman Sachs note, is to pay out a dividend to Apple shareholders. Another choice: Apple could develop a new device that’s smaller and cheaper than the iPad, but have more wizardry.

Even fans of Apple’s gadgets  point out that with the company plans to start selling the iPad 3 March 16, it may make little sense to drop $499 on a soon-to-be outdated iPad 2. “If you buy stock now, in three years time you could buy two iPads,” says Scott Sutherland, analyst at Wedbush Securities, meaning the stock will likely double.

Of course, there are those who prefer the iPad 2 to shares, especially with used models selling for as much as 20% off new ones, or $420, online. “Sell at least part of your Apple stock and buy one. I don’t believe the news can get any better,” says Jeff Saut, chief investment at financial advisory firm Raymond James in St. Petersburg, Fla.

And then there are those who can’t resist buying both. “I’m an Apple stock guy,” says Scott Davis, chief growth officer at marketing consultancy Prophet.  “You have the most valuable company in the world, the most valuable brand in the world,” says Davis, who owns an iPhone, iPad, iPod, Apple TV and — after 25 years with IBM — recently swapped his PC for a Mac.


We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines. Our blogs do not require the use of your real name.

Comments (5 of 20)

View all Comments »
    • Very thankful am I because I’ve found this useful content. I’ll check this out and see if it will work on my blog too. jimp

    • By WebOsPublisher

      Download free ‘Cell phone ‘ icon in transparent PNG or icon in different sizes and in best quality
      Cell phone : Icons and PNG image on
      Chercher en françaisfr
      Search in englishen
      Buscar en espaГ±oles
      Cerca in italianoit
      Suche auf Deutschde
      Size :
      All the sizes
      at least 256px
      at least 128px
      at least 96px
      at least 64px
      at least 48px
      at least 32px
      Commercial use :
      Colors :
      Add the filter black
      Add the filter grey
      Add the filter white
      Add the filter yellow
      Add the filter orange
      Add the filter red
      Add the filter pink
      Add the filter purple
      Add the filter blue
      Add the filter green

      iconsHuman o2Cell phone icon
      background color :
      size : 48px x 48px
      weight : 2.29 Ko
      32px x 32px
      16px x 16px
      About this icon
      Author :
      Oliver Scholtz (and others)
      Pack :
      Human o2
      Views : 281 views
      Rate :
      Loading …
      Licence :
      Commercial use :
      Yes (please be free to contact the author to be sure).
      The related icons on :
      All the icons on ‘Cell phone ‘
      The icons of the pack Human o2 :
      All icons in this pack Human o2
      Some related terms
      icon bell, icon bell system, icon burner, icon cell phone, icon central node bigophone, icon Hygiaphone littorine buzzer, icon mound, icon Vignot
      Suggest your icons
      The most searched
      expГ©rience utilisateur
      Follow @FredCozic
      Fan on Facebook

      :: В© 2009-2012 в—Џ Designed and developed by FrГ©dГ©ric Cozic and edited by Ligorus ::

    • Steve Jobs created a major technology that even the Japanese have not managed to make better of. They beat us with cars, cameras, and other electronics. I thought by 2012, some Mitsubishi or Sony computer would have emerged making Microsoft, IBM and Apple into less reliable Big 3 like Ford, GM and Dodge. But somehow Apple became the American pride. I am proud to own an American Apple computer that was not defeated by the Japanese.

    • If everyone buys 1 share instead an iPad, Apple wouldnt sell iPads at all! The stock will drop and the stock buyers will lose money

    • Put it this way: If you want to make a million dollars, just buy a $1 stock today that will grow one million and one-fold in the next few years. Hindsight instigates dangerously delusional thinking. Beware those who make their livings hawking specious financial advice, but embrace the underlying message to put your money into a responsible, long-range investment plan rather than flaunting the very latest gadgets and other trophies of conspicuous consumption. Over the long haul, diversified index funds tend to outperform quests for the next AAPL.

About Real-Time Advice

  • How breaking news — in the markets, Washington, and around the world — affects you and your money. Have a question about how current events may change your financial future? Email us at